Home › Painting guide
Painting guide

Hiring a painter: what homeowners praise, what they complain about, and straight answers

This page pulls together what homeowners in the southwest and west suburbs bring up most when they talk about the painters they hired. Some of it is what they were glad to get. Some of it is what went wrong. The posts below go deeper on each topic.

We put it in one place because most painting problems start before the first can is opened. They start with a vague estimate, a question nobody asked, or an expectation that never got written down. If you know what to look for and what to ask, you can hire any painter with a clearer picture of what you are paying for.

Guides

Read before you hire a painter

Why exterior painting waits on the weather

Outside, the weather has as much say in how paint turns out as the crew does. Here is what rain, heat, humidity and cold nights do to fresh paint, what good exterior prep looks like, and why a moved day beats a finish that fails.

Read it ›
What homeowners value

What homeowners value most in a painter

Showing up when they said and finishing when they said

Homeowners notice when a crew starts on the day it was booked and wraps up in the time it quoted. Before you sign, ask for a start date, the hours the crew will be at your house, and how many days the work should take. Ask how they will tell you if any of that changes.

Floors and furniture protected, and the house cleaned up

A good crew covers floors and furniture, moves pieces out of the way, and puts them back where they were. The work area gets picked up at the end of each day, not only on the last one. Our crew covers floors and furniture, moves furniture and puts it back, and leaves the room cleaner than we found it.

Knowing who to talk to

People want to know the plan, get an answer when they call, and deal with someone who knows their job. Ask any painter who will be at your house and who you call with a question. With us it is one crew, and one person is accountable for your job from start to finish.

Drywall repair you cannot see after paint

Nail pops, cracks at ceiling corners, lifted tape and stained ceilings all show through fresh paint if they are not repaired first. Ask how the repairs will be done and whether ceiling texture will be matched. Our crew does the drywall repair, taping and finishing before paint, and you can text a photo to (815) 585-1750 for a fast read on a repair.

A detailed written estimate

The estimate homeowners like best lists every room, the prep, the products and the number of coats, and it points out problems they had not noticed. That kind of estimate also makes two quotes possible to compare. Ours is free, done on site and written, with every room or surface, the prep, the products and the coats listed.

Clean lines on trim, ceilings and high walls

Straight lines where the wall meets the ceiling and smooth trim and doors are what people see every day. Two-story foyers, stairwells and vaulted ceilings take the right ladders or staging and a crew that has done them before. Ask what goes on trim and doors, and ask how the crew will reach the tallest wall in your house.

Cabinets done the right way

Cabinet painting holds up when the doors and drawers come off, get labeled, and get finished separately while the boxes are painted in place. Ask how the doors are finished, where that work happens, and how long your kitchen will be out of use. Ask whether new hardware is part of the job or something you handle.

Exterior prep before any paint goes on

Washing, scraping, priming and replacing rotted trim or siding boards are what make exterior paint last. Bushes, windows and walkways should be covered while the crew works. Ask what prep is included and which boards will be replaced, and know that we only paint outside on dry days warm enough for the paint to cure.

Straight answers

What homeowners complain about, answered up front

These are the complaints that come up most often after a painting job. We would rather answer them before you hire anyone, us included, because nearly every one of them can be headed off with a clear estimate and a few direct questions.

Why was my painting quote so much higher than another one?
Painting quotes differ mostly because of what is included. One quote may cover two coats, drywall repair, priming stains, ceilings, trim and moving furniture, and another may cover one coat on the walls. Put the quotes side by side and compare them line by line: rooms, surfaces, prep, products and coats. If one is half the other, ask the lower one what is left out and ask the higher one what you are paying for. Our written estimate lists every room or surface, the prep, the products and the number of coats so you can make that comparison.
What if a room needs an extra coat after we start?
Going from a dark color to a light one, or using a color that does not cover well, can take another coat. A good painter should flag that at the estimate, but sometimes it only shows after the first coat dries. With us, anything that changes, an extra coat included, is priced in writing and approved by you before it is done. Ask any painter how they handle an extra coat before you sign, so the answer is not a surprise on the bill.
What if the crew misses spots?
A few missed spots at the end of a job are common, and they are easiest to fix while the crew and the paint are still at your house. That is why we do a final walkthrough with you before we call the job done. Walk every room in good light and point at anything you see. If you hire someone else, ask whether a walkthrough is part of the job and how touch-ups found later are handled.
What if I hate the color on the wall?
A chip in the store and a full wall under your lighting can look like two different colors. That is why we put color samples on the wall before a full room is committed. Look at the samples in the morning and at night before you decide. If you change your mind after a room is painted, repainting it is a change, and we price it in writing for your approval before any work is done.
What if I notice something during the job?
Say something the same day. A crew can fix a drip, a rough patch or a missed edge in minutes while they are still set up, and it turns into a return trip once they have packed up. Tell the person running your job, or call or text (815) 585-1750. Problems that never get mentioned never get fixed, so do not save them for the end.
What if something in my house gets damaged?
Walk the house with the painter before work starts and decide what gets moved, what gets covered and what is off limits, including which sink, if any, can be used for cleanup. We carry liability insurance and can give you the certificate before work starts. Our crew covers floors and furniture and moves furniture and puts it back. If something does get damaged, take a photo and raise it right away with the person running the job. Ask any painter how they handle damage before you hire them.
Why does exterior painting keep getting pushed back?
Exterior paint needs dry surfaces and temperatures warm enough to cure, and rain, heavy humidity or extreme heat can all push a day. Painting anyway to hold a date is how you end up with peeling paint later. We only do exterior work on dry days warm enough to cure, and we tell you when weather moves a day. Ask any painter for a start window instead of a single date, and ask how they will let you know when it shifts.
What if materials like cabinet doors are delayed?
Ordered items like new cabinet doors or replacement boards come from suppliers, and suppliers run late or ship short. Before you sign, ask what is being ordered, who orders it, and whether work starts before it arrives or after. Count the pieces when they show up so a shortage gets caught that day, not at the end. If a delay changes the plan, ask for the new plan in writing.
How do I know the crew is working safely?
Ask any painter how they will set up ladders or staging for stairwells and high walls, and how they will keep your kids and pets away from the work area. Ask whether their workers are covered by workers' compensation, because a worker hurt on your property is a real risk to you. We carry liability insurance and can give you the certificate before work starts. If something about a setup looks wrong to you, say so right away.
FAQ

Painting questions

How do I get a painting estimate?
Call or text (815) 585-1750 to set up a free on-site estimate. We walk the rooms or the outside of the house with you and give you a written estimate that lists every room or surface, the prep, the products and the number of coats.
How long does a painting job take?
It depends on how many rooms or surfaces there are, how much repair is needed first, how many coats the colors take and how long each coat needs to dry. Exterior work also depends on the weather. Ask any painter for the expected number of days in writing before you sign.
What prep goes into a good paint job?
Most of the work happens before paint goes on: patching holes and cracks, sanding, caulking gaps in trim, and priming stains or bare drywall. Outside, it is washing, scraping, priming and replacing rotted boards. On your end, take down wall hangings and put away breakables in the rooms being painted.
Do I need to move my furniture?
No. Our crew moves furniture, covers floors and furniture, and puts everything back. It helps if you clear out valuables, electronics and anything fragile before we arrive.
Can we stay home with kids and pets while you paint?
Most families stay home during interior painting. Keep kids and pets out of the rooms being worked on, away from ladders and wet paint, and keep the rooms aired out. Ask any painter about lower-odor products if anyone in the house is sensitive to smells.
Do you fix drywall before painting?
Yes. Our crew does drywall repair, taping and finishing before paint, so nail pops, cracks and patches do not show through. Text a photo to (815) 585-1750 for a fast read on a repair.
Do I need a permit to paint my house?
Painting usually does not need a permit. Work beyond paint, like replacing large sections of drywall or siding, may, so check with your village if you are unsure. If you have an HOA, ask whether exterior colors need approval, and if your home was built before 1978, ask any painter how they handle lead-safe work.
Can I see proof of insurance before work starts?
Yes. We carry liability insurance, and the certificate is available before work starts. Ask any painter you are considering for the same thing, and ask for it before the first day, not after.
Free estimate

Get a written painting estimate

Call or text (815) 585-1750 to set up a free on-site estimate. You get every room or surface, the prep, the products and the number of coats in writing, and nothing changes until you approve it in writing first.

Call or text (815) 585-1750
Email matt@onitcc.com

Or call or text (815) 585-1750. We reply during business hours.

Call (815) 585-1750Get an Estimate